Women’s gymnastics is one of the most popular Olympic events, but the way the sport evolved made it ripe for abuse and overtraining. Sports scholar and former international gymnast Georgia Cervin joins us to talk about her book, Degrees of Difficulty: How Women’s Gymnastics Rose to Prominence and Fell From Grace. We talk about the beginnings of the sport as a display of feminity and how Cold War rivalries led to younger competition and created an environment that led to multiple types of abuse. We also talk about how the sport itself has changed over the decades, the introduction of the Code of Points and how stars like Simone Biles are pushing the envelope and showing what women are achieving in this sport.
Following up on our news about Tokyo 2020 golden mailboxes, Listener Don reminded us that London 2012 did the same thing (Paris 2024 and LA 2028, we hope you’re taking note and make it a trend).
What are our TKFLASTANIs up to this week? We’ve got news from:
- Karateka Tom Scott
- Boxer Ginny Fuchs (check out Texas Monthy’s film on her)
- Modern Pentathlete Samanta Schultz
- Bobsledder Josh Williamson (featured here)
- Bobsledder Lauren Gibbs
We also have news from Tokyo 2020, including:
- The constantly changing policies on spectators at the Olympics
- The Athletes’ Village pre-opening
- How some nations’ athletes are getting to the Games
- Status updates on Caster Semenya and Sha’Carri Richardson
Thanks so much for listening, and until next time, keep the flame alive!
If you liked this story, be sure to check out these episodes:
Get more great stories in our free weekly newsletter!
Photo credit: University of Illinois Press
Note: Links to products may be affiliate links. We may earn commissions through purchases made through them.
TRANSCRIPT
Note: This is an uncorrected machine-generated transcript and may contain errors. Please check its accuracy against the audio. Do not quote from the transcript; use the audio as the record of note.
198-Historian Georgia Cervin on the Evolution of Women’s Gymnastics
Georgia Cervin: [00:00:00] So it’s always this push and pull across every apparatus. Actually, the fi makes the apparatus safer. The gymnasts do harder things and it, so it’s this continual, this balancing of risk and safety,
Theme Music
Jill Jaracz: Hello fans of TKFLASTAN and welcome to another episode of keep the flame alive. The podcast four fans of the Olympics in Paralympics. I am your host. Jill Jr. Joined as always by my lovely co-host Allison brown, Allison. Hello, how are you today? ,
Alison Brown: this is my two week notice.
Jill Jaracz: we’re not quitting on [00:01:00] us.
Alison Brown: So if anyone is planning to quit their jobs before the Olympics, , this is your deadline.
We got two weeks,
Jill Jaracz: it’s coming up way quicker than, you know, I just, I keep seeing posts on feeds and because feeds don’t, they don’t want to show you necessarily the most recent thing. They wanna show you the most popular, the algorithms getting a lot of like it’s 20 days left and I get that like three or four days in a row, and now I’m just totally lost.
Alison Brown: Well, it’s it is how we’re going to feel during Tokyo, because we’ll be functioning somewhat on Tokyo time.
Jill Jaracz: Mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and somewhat at home time, we will not know what day it is. I mean, we had that issue with Pyong Chan. We didn’t know what day we were on. We just sort of just kept watching the television, hoping that the next thing we were supposed to watch would come on.
Jill Jaracz: Yeah. Cause I was . So we are actually going to release the show on Tokyo time. And that will mean that, uh, [00:02:00] we will follow the Tokyo day with the show and it will come out in the, like the early afternoon, Eastern time, the same day. So when we start prime time, that’s Tokyo morning, that will be on the next day’s show.
If that makes sense.
Alison Brown: You just tell me when to show up and people can just look at the website and see when it comes from.
Jill Jaracz: Right? Right. Pretty much, pretty much that’s it. But if you’re in the us, look for it at, at the, in the middle of the day, if you’re in Europe, it’ll probably be the end of your work day.
And if you’re in Asia around Tokyo, it will come out when the Tokyo day is over. Basically that means we gotta get use Reka locks, tips for time zone travel.
Alison Brown: We, we will have to, you know, we got two weeks, so we have to adjust our body clocks, you know, use your light box. I just don’t think we’re gonna sleep for two weeks.
Jill Jaracz: I don’t either. I don’t, or we will be just catching naps here and there. Ugh. So,
Alison Brown: but all for a [00:03:00] good cause
Jill Jaracz: exactly. Uh, follow up on one of the stories we talked about recently where, uh, the Japan postal system is going to put golden mailboxes for Japanese athletes who win gold medals listener. Don mentioned that London had done this too, and I totally forgot about it, but he sent a great story.
We’ll have a link to that in the show notes. And there are just, uh, gold post boxes all over the area for people who won gold medals.
Alison Brown: Did they mark who the box is for?
Jill Jaracz: I believe so. I believe they have that. So that is very, very cool. And what else is cool? Today’s guest.
Alison Brown: Very cool.
Interview with Georgia Cervin
Jill Jaracz: We are talking with Georgia Sevan.
She is a sports scholar focused on governance, gender and gymnastics. She’s an honorary research fellow at the university of Western Australia and author of the new book, degrees of difficulty. How women’s gymnastics rose to prominence and fell from Greece. She’s a former elite gymnast [00:04:00] herself. She competed for New Zealand.
One, one of her big events inter nationally was the 2006 Commonwealth games. We talked with Georgia about the evolution of women’s gymnastics as a sport. Take a listen,
What women’s artistic gymnastics was like in the 1950s and 1960s
Alison Brown: Georgia. Thank you so much for joining us in your book. You go way back in gymnastics history, but we’re gonna start with where women’s gymnastics started in the Olympics, which is in 1952.
So what did women’s gymnastics look like in the fifties and sixties?
Georgia Cervin: Well, just one thing is that women had competed or had done gymnastics in the Olympics before then, but it wasn’t a competition. It was like an exhibition sport. So in 1952, that’s when it starts as women’s artistic gymnastics and with the four apparatus that we use now.
And so back then, it was mostly gymnasts in their twenties. Um, they were often former ballerinas and the sport. It looked very different [00:05:00] because of that. You know, they, a lot of the movements were based on ballet. There was a lot of leaps and turns and it was, it was much slower. And simpler, that was really valued.
And that was the point actually then, and even if you look at their outfits, um, you know, the leotards are cut lower in the leg and it, and wider in the shoulder, and it really emphasizes this kind of hourglass figure. And some of the gymnasts were even mothers as well, so very different to where the sport ended up some decades later.
Alison Brown: Yeah. I love watching some of the old videos with the hairdos,
Georgia Cervin: the hairdos. Yeah. There was kind of beehive kind of, yeah.
Alison Brown: It, it would definitely have thrown off your center of gravity.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. I don’t, I genuinely don’t understand how they did that.
The 1970s changes gymnastics
Alison Brown: so the grumblings of change come in 1972 and then obviously the big change in 76 with Nadia from Romania, but we saw it in 72 with Olga Corbit from then the [00:06:00] Soviet union.
So they sort of usher in this new era. And you talk a lot about that era in your book. So what was different about them both physically and the kind of moves that they were doing?
Georgia Cervin: Well, there had been, uh, some younger gymnasts performing this kind of acrobatic style actually in the sixties, but they weren’t very well known outside of gymnastics and they didn’t always do very well inside gymnastics.
It wasn’t particularly rewarded, but that style was really popularized in 1972 by alga Corbat and the, the world kind of knew about it and that public kind of support and popularity for this new style kind of meant there was no turning back, um, for the gymnastics Federation. And so what they. Both Olga and Nadia really did is the style that is more, almost like more airborne.
So a lot more acrobatics, way more time [00:07:00] off the ground. It was a lot kind quicker dynamic and, and risky as well, which is something that was discouraged for women because women have seen as fragile basically. And so this was, uh, a very new direction and Olga wasn’t actually a child. She was, she was 17 when she debuted this, this kind of style, but she kind of.
Had a persona that was intentionally developed to be childlike. So she wore a hair and pigtails, she kind of skipped around on the floor. She would smile to the audience, she would cry. And so it kind of portrayed this image of childishness, of needing kind of adult, uh, supervision or protection and this kind of fragility.
And then Nadia in 1976, she was a child. She was 14. And she, she was a lot more serious in [00:08:00] her style and her personality, but she also had routines that were made to look like she was a child. She mimicked child’s play in some of her dance, but it was more of a kind of professional, strict athlete, uh, kind of style.
But with both of them getting. success at the Olympics with those styles, it made a change throughout the world because people then emulate what they did to achieve the success. So people started working with younger athletes and they started trying to show these, uh, more acrobatic and risky kinds of gymnastics.
Alison Brown: So I was a Nadia baby. I was one of those kids who saw it and decided that that was, that was what I wanted to do. And it also fed into, they were very approachable. You know, it wasn’t like the, the other Soviet or Eastern block women who were very [00:09:00] serious. Mm-hmm and cold and, and here’s Olga Corbit crying and laughing and Nadia looking, you know, just so sweet and young and adorable.
You talk a lot, a lot in the book about this sort of diplomacy and reflection of what was happening at the times as well.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah, it’s funny because both of them really appeal to Western audiences. It really broke down this perception of like the machine kind of athlete, this really stoic unapproachable kind of person, but.
The Soviet union actually did not like or, but because they kind of thought she was uncontrollable they, they couldn’t tell what she was gonna do. Was she gonna cry? Was she gonna laugh? And so that wasn’t great for them, but both countries, both Romania and the Soviet union could see the appeal and the popularity that these two gymnasts were gaining in the west.
And so they kind of, they [00:10:00] sent their gymnasts on these, on gymnastics tours and throughout America, um, great Britain and Australia, but the gymnastics tours were really about winning winning hearts and minds and support for the Soviet union in Romania. And they, they did get a lot of fans actually from it.
Jill Jaracz: You know, it’s interesting. Cuz in the book you mentioned a Nadia got the first perfect 10, but literally right behind her was Nellie Kim.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Jill Jaracz: Other, so I kind of wonder if. Timing had been different. How would we think today? And would Nadia still be the same darling? Cuz Nelly Kim’s a pretty big powerhouse too.
I mean, I was watching some of her tumbling passes on floor exercise today and it was, it was impressive, especially when you think 1976.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. A lot of the stuff she did was really groundbreaking and it’s stuff like the stuff that Nel Kim did is still considered quite difficult. So I think that’s a great question.
Something I thought about as well, [00:11:00] if Nel Kim had gone first, you know, it all might be different, but the other thing is really Nadia’s dominance. So she didn’t, she got seven perfect tens across, I think two apparatus Nel cam also got more than one, but I think the differences that commande was just seen as so dominant and so difficult to beat across the board.
Very similar to how we talk about Simone viles today.
Alison Brown: Yeah, Nel Nelly. Kim was not a darling.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Alison Brown: She was a very classical Soviet gymnast in, in, you know, LA middle to Sheva. And that whole group mm-hmm who were on that team with Olga Corbit were not Olga Corbit. So when you say the Soviets didn’t cuz the rest of the team was not like Olga.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah, exactly. And I think maybe that’s part of the appeal to Western audiences. Like Olga was doing something really different and surprising. And what Nelly was doing [00:12:00] is very consistent with what the Soviet union has already done. Granted going further and better, but it’s not, um, I guess it didn’t have that same appeal to Western audiences.
Alison Brown: No definitely. It was, you know, I didn’t learn about Nellie Kim or to Sheva until I was 10 years older.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Alison Brown: You know, those names didn’t mean anything until it didn’t capture the imagination of the little girls who filled certainly American gyms and probably a lot of Western gyms in the late seventies.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. Like both of both Nadia and Olga after their, the kind of popularity boom. In the seventies, gymnastics participation increased like threefold in America. Um, I think I don’t have the stats for the rest of the world, but I know anecdotally that it that’s the reason a lot of people, a lot of women were put into gymnastics and not just women, girls.
It was really seen as [00:13:00] a girl sport after that. And so it’s a little bit. Self perpetuating, right? Like they created this image and then people, parents were like, oh, this is a great place to put my child kind of thing.
The IOC implements a minimum age for Olympic gymnastics, and China flaunts the rules
Alison Brown: So it very much became, like you said, a girl’s sport and you have this great chart in the book about the average age of the Olympic gymnasts, just plummeting, uh, in, in the eighties and not really climbing very much at all until sort of probably this year, they’re going up a little bit, Jill and I were talking about this earlier and they just seemed to get smaller and smaller and younger and younger through the whole eighties and nineties.
And they were doing Wilder and Wilder. Treks.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. So. They definitely got smaller and the gymnastics got harder. And the fig that’s the international body created minimum age rules because they could see this trend happening and they could [00:14:00] see that people were starting to criticize them for it, both the general public and the international Olympic committee.
And so they had an international, they had a minimum age of 14. They increased it to 15 in the eighties and 16 in the nineties. And when they did that last one in the nineties, the average age was actually over 16. So they kind of implemented this rule after a shift increasing the age had already begun.
Um, and the minimum age is still at 16. The other thing about the increasing difficulties, the, the equipment changes just minor changes, but you know, the Springs get a bit better. The mat, the mats get a bit softer and it’s just basic kind of technological advancements rather than any kind of specifically new pieces of equipment.
Alison Brown: So I wanna, I wanna put a pin in that, cuz I see Jill about to jump in with her equipment, but I wanna ask a little bit about the age because the dropping of the ages kind of [00:15:00] culminates in 2008 where the Chinese team is ultimately disqualified because they had gymnasts possibly as young as 12 competing and faking their ages.
So what is fig doing now to ensure. That’s not happening
Georgia Cervin: well in 2008 that Chinese team didn’t get disqualified. There’s no evidence that that team did falsify their ages, but there was a lot of media commentary about it based on how small those gymnasts look. And, uh, I guess the youth of their faces, however, the team, the 2000 team was disqualified.
And that was because eight years after they competed one of the gymnasts registered to be a judge at, at the opics and she had a different age then. And so that’s when the pieces came together and [00:16:00] they, the officials could see these ages are not consistent. This person must have been a different age when they were competing.
And. The only way that fig can really enforce the age rule is by looking at people’s, uh, like their passports, those kind of ID documents that include people’s ages, but it’s the governments that create those documents. And so there has to be a kind of a system where those nations agree to play by the rules, or they can falsify those documents.
And I don’t know how the FIG would, would know if they’re falsified until there starts to be inconsistency across those documents over time.
Alison Brown: Yeah. Maybe it was the 2000 team. Cause I remember one of the Chinese gymnasts was missing a tooth.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Alison Brown: Like she had lost a tooth and I remember looking at it going, I don’t think she’s 16.
Jill Jaracz: So another thing that we were talking about earlier is. [00:17:00] Is the average age starting to rise, because one of the things about the Tokyo games is that the fi said, uh, when the Tokyo games got, uh, postponed, the fig also kind of expanded the age limit so that if you would have been minimum age for the Paris games, which is where we’re in, we’re technically in the Paris game quad.
If you’re thinking about it for federations, if you would’ve qualified for, for this year in the minimum age, you could still go to Tokyo or try to qualify for Tokyo, but basically people there are gymnasts. And, and we saw a couple on the team from Russia who would not have qualified last year, cuz they didn’t meet the age minimum, but did qualify this year.
But then we were looking at a lot of teams and noticed that. Gymnast seemed to be getting older today. Does, does that have any correlation with the types of tricks they’re doing? Because stuff is really difficult [00:18:00] now
Georgia Cervin: mm-hmm so there has been a increase in the average age, probably for the last decade, at least.
And it was over 20 at world championships for the first time, maybe around 2014. So it’s, it’s been slowly creeping up and now, especially the, um, the American team, I think their average age is I think it’s 21. So that’s a really big change, especially for the us. So this trend is, has been underway for a while.
I’m not sure if it’s related to the type of gymnastics and like the difficulty of the skills that people are doing. I think it’s potentially related to a couple of innovations that F IG made. Over a decade ago that allowed gymnasts to specialize so they can do one apparatus or, you know, two or three, but they, before that you had to do four.
So that means you can train a little bit less, you know, you can focus your energy [00:19:00] onto one thing. And the demand is a bit lighter because of that. I think also one of the biggest factors is actually there’s been a really great role model in gymnastics, Oxana S who. Has been to, she, she went to her first Olympics in 1992 and she’s still going.
And I think a lot of people have watched what she’s done and realized that you don’t have to stop after you are 16. And in fact, you can get better. And I know she’s been an inspiration to a lot of people. And as those people have continued, their careers they’ve become the inspiration as well. And so now there’s this much bigger pool of athletes who are older and they’re all proving it.
And. One at the moment that everyone loves is Chelsea mem and she didn’t make the American team, unfortunately, but she, she was a 2008 [00:20:00] Olympian and she’s had two kids. And in the last, I think two years she’s been documenting her return to gymnastics on Instagram. And it’s been really amazing to watching it.
I think it’s, again, inspired a lot of former gymnasts to wonder if they too could actually do it.
How older gymnasts are changing the sport
Alison Brown: So with the age going up, one of the things that we talk a lot about, unfortunately with gymnastics is all the abuse scandals and not just the sexual abuse and the physical abuse, but kind of training abuse that these girls are sort of trained into the ground.
So. . Is there a change coming with that increase in age of training methods?
Georgia Cervin: Yeah, so I was part of the study that I did with, um, scholars from Sweden and Brazil and Canada. And we talked to older gymnasts and asked how their training had [00:21:00] changed to account for the fact they were older and across the board, they said they had a lot more control over what they were doing.
So when they were younger, it was a really authoritarian relationship with the coach. It was do what you’re told. Don’t question me all the rest of it. And as the gymnasts got older, they just, they wouldn’t stand for that. They would push back and say, no, I’m not doing that. I don’t like my, my body is too sore.
I am too tired and that is too dangerous. I’m not doing it. And the gymnasts that were able to continue their coaches. Really had to kind of take a step back and rethink how they were coaching and the coaches that could move towards more of a partnership instead of that authoritarian method, those were the ones who were able to sustain the careers of their gymnasts.
And that was essentially the key point that makes it work. And knowing that now I think there’s [00:22:00] scope for that kind of more partnership way of coaching to be applied to younger gymnasts as well. But gymnasts are really taught when they’re young to not ask questions, to be docile and passive and yeah, and I think they, they need to be taught how to feel their bodies and know what they need, not just to listen kind of blindly and follow yeah.
Follow instructions blindly.
How abusive coaching came to be
Alison Brown: so going back to, you know, that time in the seventies and the eighties where you have the huge success in, of Eastern European gymnast, obviously, especially Soviets and Romanians, and then the Corollas come to America and kind of bring that style of coaching that you were just talking about and then American gymnastics community kind of accepted that.
So what, what about either gymnastics or the coaching? Did we all accept that [00:23:00] the coach could just kind of control your life as, as to these very young girls?
Georgia Cervin: Well, it wasn’t just the Corollas because this is around the world and it’s, the coaching was like that before the fall of the Soviet union as well.
So before a lot of these Eastern block coaches moved everywhere, and it’s, I think it’s to do with both the age of athletes and the gender. So one of the kind of important things about femininity has historically been that women are passive and do, and they do what they’re told. They, you don’t be difficult.
You don’t ask questions and often don’t take a leadership position, right? You, you are often subordinate or supposed to be subordinate to men or other authorities. And the reason [00:24:00] that is exacerbated in gymnastics is because the, the point of gymnastics of women’s gymnastics is to showcase femininity. So these aren’t just females in sport, they’re females who are trying to be feminine in sport.
And so they’re encouraged to have these behaviors of being subordinate and following. This authoritarian model and then exacerbating, that is the fact that they’re children and children also get those messages of, you know, don’t ask questions, adults know better. And so there’s a lot of trust put in the coach and a lot of autonomy taken away from the female child gymnast.
And I think because of those two factors, it’s kind of been seen as appropriate in gymnastics as it’s quite paternalistic. Um, the adults, the coaches know better, and you just have to trust that this is how it’s done.
Evolution of gymnastics apparatuses
Alison Brown: So I promise [00:25:00] Jill, we would go back to equipment because the one thing that Jill always talks about is the bars
Georgia Cervin: mm-hmm ,
Alison Brown: you know, in the old days you would beat the bar, you, it was close enough that with your hands are on the high bar, you could whip your, your hips onto the low bar.
And now they just keep getting further and further and further.
Jill Jaracz: Yeah. When did that start happening specifically with bars, and then you talked a little bit about the, the vault has changed too. And I’ve, I do notice that as well, but, well, that’s kind of a separate thing. Mm-hmm, more so on, on bars. Why, when did they start getting farther apart and why?
Okay,
Georgia Cervin: so actually it’s always been happening. So at the, in the very first Olympics that women were competing in, they were using the men’s parallel bars with one bar up one bar down. And so they would just stand on the bottom one and hold the top one as like a balance. And it was essentially, that was the apparatus.
So it was like a balancing kind of posing. and they [00:26:00] got a little bit further apart and people started to do, you know, the swing down and hit your hips and bounce back up kind of thing. And spin like around the bars. And then in the sixties, there was an American gymnast actually, who trained with, I think she trained with a male coach.
And so she was kind of practicing like a, the style, the menus on the hi, but she applied that to the parallel bars, to the uneven bars. So she started doing more swinging more like she would like release the bar and twist and catch and that kind of thing. And she, I mean, it wasn’t particularly celebrated or rewarded in gymnastics, but it was a, it was a star that kind of planted the seed.
And I guess the, the hip kind of beating stuff and the, those kind of half swings kept on happening and getting bigger and bigger and bigger. And. On in the men’s high bar, they started [00:27:00] like releasing the bar and catching it again. And women saw that started applying it to their, their bars, required it to the bars to get further away so that they could gain enough momentum to do those things.
So that was really, um, maybe around the eighties and that that started happening. And then in the nineties, they got further apart to allow even bigger circles around the bar to get more air time off the bar and reca it. And that evolution has kind of con so it’s kind of continued since the beginning of the sport.
I think the distance now is similar to what it was a decade or two ago. So I think I’m not sure if it would continue to change that much from now. Yeah. For the. Vault in 2001, they, they changed the vaulting horse. [00:28:00] So before it was called a vaulting horse, because it was modeled off a, a literal horse. So it’s quite like narrow.
And it was around for women. It was around like 125 centimeters off the ground. And there were some really serious injuries. At least two people were paralyzed from doing that, that vault. And so it took about at least a decade actually, but the international governing body had been developing a neuro arthritis that they thought would be safer with more, uh, like safety padding, a bigger surface area.
So there’s less risk, less risk that people would miss their hands or slip off the vault. And they also wanted something that was gonna be easier to, for both men and women to use, because before you had to move the horse to cuz the men would use it in a different direction to women, and these are really he pieces of equipment and it’s just quite impractical.
So the [00:29:00] new horse that, or the table is what they call it, that they invented in 2001 is, is effectively unisex. They just use different Heights and it’s softer. It’s got a bigger surface area and it’s therefore safer. But because of all those things, because it’s safer, safer, and add a little bit kinda springier gymnast, then do harder stuff on it.
So it’s always this push and pull across every apparatus. Actually the fi makes the apparatus safer. The gymnasts do harder things and it, so it’s this continual. This balancing of risk and safety. And then just more generally, like on the floor, they added Springs in, I think the seventies and just technological advancements, those Springs have gotten springier and the mats have gotten softer.
And so that’s why we see much harder tumbling now than we used to on beam. It used to be like sharp, a piece of wood, and it was just a sharp wooden [00:30:00] corners and that’s it. And they, then they put like leather around the outside. So you wouldn’t get scraped if you fell. And then they put padding underneath the leather and it became a little bit bouncier.
And so again, it’s just increasing safety, increasing risk .
Jill Jaracz: Does the floor really. as loud as it does on TV or are they, it really does, or, cause I figured they’re micing it too.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. And that’s a great question. I feel like it does sound that loud, but it’s kind of more emphasized on TV because when you are in a gym, there’s like probably a hundred people in there.
Everyone’s doing everything at once. Moving mats, every like the mats crash down when you move, when you flip them and stuff. And so there’s so much happening, you don’t, I feel like you don’t notice it as, as much as you do in a competition.
Why gymnastics moves are named after people
Jill Jaracz: Speaking of harder and harder tricks, gymnastics is unique in that tricks are named after the first person to do them in a [00:31:00] world competition.
Cause you don’t see that in like diving, which also could potentially have similar moves or in, in some of the aerial snow sports. But why did that come about and how does that continue to develop?
Georgia Cervin: That’s a really good question. So. Some of the more basic things like, like handstand, Cartwheel, all those foundational things.
There’s no way that those are ever gonna be named after the first performer. But I think I’m, I’m guessing here I’m hypothesizing, but I think it’s because. Some element, some skills you can’t describe. So for example, front flip, you can describe double front flip. You can describe that as well, but on bar, when someone does, for example, they swing up and let go, and then change the way they’re moving and come back down on the other side and catch it.
Like you [00:32:00] can’t describe that as like, it’s not really a flip, but it’s, it’s kind of a reverse. And so there’s not really existing language for it. And so it becomes named after that person. And then after that, you can describe it. So I was, what I was trying to describe then was a catch chef. And then you could call it a pike catch chef if you do it with your legs together instead of straddled.
But because that precedent exists of naming stuff after people, well, if you do a different variation of that, you wanna get your, you wanna the credit for it. You wanna be imortalized in the real book of the sport. So you apply to have your name put on it. And I know for a lot of people, that’s a goal in and of itself.
You, you might not be able to get a gold medal, but you can get your name in that book and everyone will say your name, whoever does that skill in their life. And that’s pretty cool.
Jill Jaracz: It is very cool. And it also helps the rest of us learn how to speak Russian.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah, exactly. It may. It does make it really hard to come into the sport as a [00:33:00] spectator because you know, the commentators are describing.
What the gymnast is doing, and they’re basically speaking another language and then it takes a while to, to catch on to what they’re saying, but then once you know yeah. It’s, it’s really cool.
The development of the Code of Points
Alison Brown: okay. So that that’s a good lead to code of points, discussion. So it used to be based outta 10
Georgia Cervin: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and now we have this, this move has a particular point.
It ultimately could be limitless as to what the, the amount of points. So one, why was that change made and how does that change affect the spectator and how were we’re kind of watching the sport?
Georgia Cervin: So that change was made. Um, the change had been mooted for quite a long time, actually since maybe the early nineties.
As a way of striking the balance between difficulty and execution in the sport, which [00:34:00] is how hard what you’re doing is versus how well you do it. Because there had been just a feeling that the, that was, had been a bit off and they also thought some officials also thought that there was a problem and that a, a great performer was, would kind of hit the ceiling of perfect 10 and a, and a good performer could be getting a 9.9.
And the difference between those two performances is not really just one 10th, but they got like stuck within that perfect 10 system. But a lot of the gymnastics world did not want a change like that. That was it’s crazy. It’s way too, out there. And so nothing really happened with it. And then there was a number of judging scandals, particularly.
The 2004 Olympics and the men’s competition and the IOC was putting pressure on the fig to basically clean up their act. They were saying, you know, this sport is not fair and it’s [00:35:00] because it’s not fair. It’s, it’s not very credible and you need to sort yourselves out. So they did very quickly. They had this, this new version that they had been in the background since the 1990s, and they just pulled it back outta the archive and put it in as the new system.
And so the new system, it separates difficulty in execution. And the way it does that is there’s, there’s two scores. So your execution, you have deductions from 10 points and they’re like one 10th for a small step on your landing to a whole point for a fall and various deductions in between. And then the other score is your difficulty score and your top 10 skills are added up because each skill has a difficulty rating from about one 10th to nine tenths.
So they add that all up and that’s basically how you get your difficulty score. And then you add the two components together. And that’s why you end up with like a, [00:36:00] a score of 15. Often the execution score would be somewhere around eight and often the difficulty score would be somewhere around, I dunno, six, seven.
Alison Brown: So every quad they revamp the code of points.
Georgia Cervin: Yes.
Alison Brown: Yeah. Yes. Okay. So based on kind of what, what happened last time around, we’re gonna make some changes. What do you see as being favored right now in the code of points?
Georgia Cervin: Hmm. I don’t know if I can, if I can comment about what I see as being favored. I can say more generally though, that.
If the fig sees, sees a prevalence of a lot of a certain skill, for example, Wolf turns gen actually gymnastics fans would know about that Wolf turns. So it’s like a pro, but when you’re kind of in like a squat position, too many people are doing those. And so the fig would say, they’re not gonna say you can’t do it, but they’re gonna say, instead of getting, you [00:37:00] know, I know five tens for that.
You’re only gonna get one because it it’s a way of disincentivizing it basically, maybe a decade ago, you used to be able to, when you land your tumbles, you’d do like a step into a lunge afterwards. And the FIG said, we don’t want that anymore. And so that’s now that became a deduction so they can add new deductions in and they can also reevaluate the level of difficulty.
Or the reward, they’ll give you for certain skills and that’s how they shape what the sport looks like and where it’s going. But it’s very reactionary. It’s based on what they’ve seen rather than, oh, it is also what they anticipate actually, but it’s easier to be an, uh, yeah, reactionary.
Jill Jaracz: I may be wrong on this cause I’m going off a memory.
Isn’t the new code of points for that would end in 20, 24. That is out now. Correct. And it will be starting next year.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. So the codes are, they come into force after the [00:38:00] Olympics, um, and didn’t have the Olympic. So the new code was written and ready to go. But as, as far as I understand it, we are competing under the old code, the code that was meant to finish in 2020, because it’s a bit unfair to change the rules.
Now I might be wrong, but that’s what I understand is happening. And the new code will kick in after the Olympics for other competitions.
Jill Jaracz: Right. So I think my, my question kind of is like, don’t they sometimes see where, what the, what happens at the Olympics and kind of use that to help finalize their, the, the new code.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Jill Jaracz: Or do they not have enough time for that? Cause I, I know how rules take long how long it takes to get rules done.
Georgia Cervin: I understand that that is what they do. So they’ll have the draft ready to go. It’s a huge document, like hundreds of pages. And so they will have drafted that and have the general idea of where they’re going and what they wanna do.
But I think they can make some. Amendments after the [00:39:00] Olympics. I dunno if that’ll be the case this year, but I think that’s usually how it works.
Jill Jaracz: Yeah. Cause I was very curious on like how, if something, well, we could talk about Simone in the new vault, which, what is it? You’re a Chino. Yeah. Double. Okay.
Georgia Cervin: You
Jill Jaracz: just, it can just have memory, but uh, you know, her, if she throws down that new vault and they’re like, it, it seems like the fi is kind of like, whoa, we don’t know about this one.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. Well, I, I think the vault is a bit different than the be dismount, which there was a bit of a drama that, that was really undervalued and they made that case by looking at the value on floor and then comparing to the value on beam. And it’s a bit inconsistent, whereas the vault, there’s not the same kind of direct comparison that can be made like that.
Can’t be done something similar. Can’t be done on any of the other apparatus. So it’s. Uh, there’s not really a benchmark to measure [00:40:00] against, except for the men’s vault. The men do that vault. And if you look at the difference between the men’s value for other vaults, and then how it’s valued on the women’s vault, the Eugene double, Pike’s pretty similar.
Like there’s a similar difference in the men’s and women’s values. So it’s, it seems to be consistent actually, but we already had this narrative of, um, Simone gets penalized for her difficulty. And so it kind of fit quite neatly into that without there really being the same kind of evidence to support that narrative.
Simone Biles: Artistic gymnastics leader
Alison Brown: Okay. So let’s, let’s talk about Simone because obviously she’s the biggest star in the sport. Arguably gonna be the biggest star in Tokyo
Georgia Cervin: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and she is doing things that have never been done before.
Georgia Cervin: Mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and a level of difficulty we’ve never seen. And is that good for. Sport of women’s gymnastics as a whole.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. Yeah. It’s amazing. She’s [00:41:00] been amazing for women’s gymnastics because she’s really pushing the envelope of not just what can be done, but what could even be imagined. And she’s a real leader in the sport, not just with her gymnastics, but she has taken public opinions on a lot of issues. And I think that’s a kind of leadership that not all athletes have.
You know, it’s a really important platform that they’ve given and not everyone uses it. And particularly when gymnastics has been in crisis for the last few years, with all of the abuse, she’s emerged as a great leader for the sport. So watch her for a gymnastics, watch her for what she says. She’s been incredible for the sport.
And on top of all of that, there’s also an issue of representation she’s been doing wonders for kind of. Showing that the, this is not just a sport for white girls and other people have [00:42:00] shown that before her, but she’s still part of that, that journey. And I think, you know, that’s really important.
Jill Jaracz: Do you see it because it it’s interesting.
The roots of gymnastics are European kind of military or femininity, and that bias seems to play out. Or at least we in America hear that narrative because we end up having a lot of, uh, some of the gymnasts of color who have broken that barrier, but there still seems to be an underlying whiteness to the sport or to the governance of the sport.
Do, do you see that changing much?
Georgia Cervin: Yeah.
Jill Jaracz: Or am I being accurate?
Georgia Cervin: You, you are being accurate. I think I, it’s hard to say if it’s changing much. I think we, we see the change in non elite gymnastics. So if you look at collegiate gymnastics, for example, they’re doing kind of different styles of dance and that kind of thing.
And it it’s a bit more [00:43:00] open because if you think about it, like people have been doing flips and dancing and lots of cultures around the world for hundreds of years and none of those, well, not all of those things are called gymnastics. Gymnastics is this narrow a narrow thing where you are expected to do BEIC type movements, tumbling that meets these kind of expectations.
I mean, when was the last time you saw a female gymnast doing dancing to hip hop at the Olympics? You know, and that’s just a simple way of saying, you know, the music choices, the hairstyles, all of that is it’s quite white. And even though there’s non-white gymnasts, they often are being asked to conform to those white expectations.
Whereas yeah, if you look at, I’m just thinking about the UCLA women’s gymnastics team, and you know, earlier this year they had a routine, they, they were calling it black excellence. I think it was near Dennis and that kind of thing. You know, you listen to the [00:44:00] music choices, look at the dance moves, they’re all referencing black culture.
And it’s those kind of cultural references that are still haven’t really made their way into the elite sport,
Jill Jaracz: which, you know, I’m, I’m hoping it does change because a as much as I enjoy. Eastern European folk music. I am really tired of watching people do floor exercises to that, that look just like a fish outta water choice.
Georgia Cervin: It would be so much more interesting if we could, if it was more diverse. And I, I hope it’s going in that way. I guess the other thing is as well as historically, the sport was governed by Europeans. Uh, anyone could be on the governance boards, but it just, it was Europeans since the eighties, it started to diversify a little bit geographically.
So that’s when the first Australian made it onto the executive board. But I mean, Australian is, that’s still, they still [00:45:00] conform to white culture. Um, so again, it’s diversifying, but is it going beyond those European values? Not sure yet, but hopefully.
Who to watch at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics
Alison Brown: and who else besides Simone, are you excited to see this time around mm-hmm
Georgia Cervin: Well, the whole American team is gonna be really interesting. Look out for Sunis Lee’s bars, everything she does, but her bars in particular are just are stunning. It’ll I know this might be controversial for gymnastics fans, but Mikayla’s Skinner. Like, it’s gonna be interesting to see how she goes. She’s gonna be giving everyone a run for their money as a bit of an, as much as an American can be an underdog.
She’s gonna fill that role. teen China will be interesting. They’re looking a lot different than they’ve looked historically, so, and they’re always a strong team, so yeah, and also team great Britain, some newcomers on that team. Dunno. What’s gonna happen. Are we interesting to see.
Jill Jaracz: What about the Russian [00:46:00] team or I’m sorry, the Russian Olympic team team from Russia.
whatever we have to call them this time around because you know, the dominance kind of faded after the, the breakup of the Soviet union, but you know, where do they stand in the world today?
Georgia Cervin: Mm they’re still highly competitive and you know, they’re gonna be, they’re gonna be up there. But I, I find it hard to comment on them because I guess what they’re doing is the more traditional stuff.
And I don’t know that that could be a great move or that could not work out so well, as it’s, it’s hard to say, I think, um, I think they’re one of the younger teams now and yeah, I mean, I dunno,
Jill Jaracz: interesting.
Alison Brown: What’s happened to Romania. You know, we started talking with Nadia and now Romania just is not even.
on anyone’s radar anymore. There’s it’s just [00:47:00] not there.
Georgia Cervin: Yeah. So they didn’t qualify a team. I think some of the analysis I’ve heard from people in Romania is that, you know, it used to be gymnastics used to be this really important nationalist kind of pursuit and a real opportunity for people to lift themselves out of poverty.
And it was quite like a privileged life. You get to go to this school, you get to have the best training, all the rest of it. And as the country has developed the sacrifice hasn’t been seen as worth it for a lot of people. So there’s been less interest from families and putting their children into domestics.
I wonder if there’s been underfunding of the national system as well. And I think. Romania kept going until the, uh, like mid 2010s. And so we didn’t really [00:48:00] see the consequences of that underfunding and that, of that change in kind of social dynamics until quite suddenly they ran out of gymnasts. And so they’ve still got excellent gymnasts, but they don’t have as, as many a struggle to put together a team.
And they’ve just, yeah, kind of gone away from the limelight, which is really sad for them. It’s been a really important sport for their country.
Jill Jaracz: Thank you so much, Georgia. We are really excited that you were able to come on the show. You thank you so much, Georgia. You can learn more about Georgia’s work@georgiasdotcomandyoucanbuyherbookandbooksbyallofourfeaturedauthorsfromtheshowthroughourbookshop.org site, we earn a commission from purchases and that goes to offsetting the costs of producing this show.
Go to bookshop.org/shop/flame live pod to get your.
Alison Brown: So I wanna make one correction and Georgia did correct me. And I just wanted to make sure that that was clear that it was the 2000 [00:49:00] Chinese women’s team that was stripped of their medal.
Jill Jaracz: Oh, right,
Alison Brown: right, right. Because of an age violation though, the 2008 team was subject to an official fig investigation.
Jill Jaracz: Okay. Thank you for clearing that up.
TKFLASTAN News
Alison Brown: Welcome to shook Stan.
Jill Jaracz: Yes. It’s time to check in with our team. Keep the flame alive. These are past guests who have been on the show. First up, Tom Scott, our karate athlete is going to Tokyo. You know why? I,
Alison Brown: I literally started jumping up and down and then I found out why, and I was not so happy.
Jill Jaracz: That is right. The world karate Federation sanctioned the top competitor in his bracket. I Iranian’s BA Aari. Uh, Goche I believe is how it pronounced is pronounced. He had a violation because of a prohibitive use of a prohibitive sub substance. [00:50:00] And he is suspended from all international competitions for a 12 month period, which means he had to, uh, revoke his place at the Olympic games.
And Tom was next in line. So Tom gets to go instead,
Alison Brown: the world is balanced again,
Jill Jaracz: right? We are very excited for you, Tom. Best of luck. We will be watching
Alison Brown: Ginny Fuchs and the USA boxing team are in Miyazaki for pre Olympics training, Texas monthly teamed with June 3rd films to tell stories of four Texans who are going to Tokyo.
And gin’s story is the first in the series and we will have a link to see that.
Jill Jaracz: And it’s really good. It’s like a seven minute short film. And it’s really interesting because it shows. how much the O C D affects her and, and how she is able to channel her energies and thoughts when she’s in the boxing ring.
Alison Brown: And we talked with her a lot about OCD. So take Alyssa back to our chat with her.
Jill Jaracz: We got our 20, 22, 20 23 team USA [00:51:00] calendar in the mail. And, you know, who’s, uh, one of the April athletes, Samantha Schultz, our modern F athlete . So they give these calendars out to, uh, people who donate. So basically if you probably got one, if you’re on their email list and you also got a, uh, donation solicitation for that, but you might be able still to still get one.
Now it was funny because, uh, I put a picture on Twitter and tagged her and she did not know she was in the calendar.
Alison Brown: well, okay. She should have been in may because may is the fifth month.
Jill Jaracz: Oh, right. And it’s five sports and modern, but.
Alison Brown: Bob SL Josh Williamson Fe was featured on sliding on ice, getting to know a slider column.
Jill Jaracz: And, uh, finally Lauren Gibbs, uh, one of our other bobs letters is auctioning off an NFT artistic rendering of herself by the artist foray. The auction goes live on July 12th and you can find out more at Lauren’s GoFundMe page. We will have a link to that in the show notes.[00:52:00]
Tokyo 2020 News
Of course, lots of Tokyo, 2020 news. COVID is not doing well in Japan. The numbers keep going up. They have hit levels. They haven’t seen since may. So we’re getting in the nine hundreds of daily cases. So that’s not great. Uh, both inside the games and the Kyodo news said that the spectator cap will likely be lowered to 5,000.
The opening ceremonies could just be in front of VIPs. Fans may be banned after 9:00 PM. The torch relay was taken off public roads. Organizers wanted fans to stay away from the marathon and the race walks that are in Sapporo. But this was great because world athletics was quote unquote surprised by this decision, which it describes as seemingly inconsistent with plans to allow spectators in the venue.
That made me laugh.
Alison Brown: Oh, that that’s sort of an addendum to the [00:53:00] Marin Nove,
Jill Jaracz: right? Yeah. Right. I know it just goes along that, that, that all wrapped together. So, um, the government, the S AHI Shinbo says the government may issue another state of emergency for Tokyo through August 22, which is not great news.
Another athlete arrived in the country with COVID. This was this time, it’s a Serbian rower, but it was also pointed out that more than 500 participants who are gonna be at the Tokyo to, uh, Olympics arrived on July 1st and no COVID cases were reported. So I think there’s a little bit of one COVID case shows up and that’s the only news we can have versus a lot of people are starting to arrive and we’re doing okay.
Uh, the, because of all of this uncertainty about how many, uh, spectators they’ll have the ticket lottery results got pushed back again to July 10th. So Roy to ZAWA, we are still hoping for you to get a couple of tickets out [00:54:00] of this, and that’s kind of where we stand with. COVID it’s, it’s just kind of a wait and see, keep hoping that measures work.
Tokyos please do your part. The Kyoto news reported that the athletes village had a pre-opening this week, mainly for officials of team delegations, who have to make preparations to welcome the athletes and support them. So people are starting to arrive in the village to make things ready. Um, speaking of athletes arriving.
There’s a, a outlet called news wire that said how some athletes in, uh, Southeast Asia and the Pacific islands were having trouble get not trouble. But their journey to Tokyo is a lot longer than they thought. So Sri Lankas normally would go through Singapore and then up to Tokyo, but Singapore is banned Sri Lankas from even transferring air in the airport.
So instead [00:55:00] they have to go through Qatar and yes. So that that’s
Alison Brown: the wrong
Jill Jaracz: direction. Yeah, exactly. So it’s a long, long, long journey for those athletes and the Fiji team. They’re going to Tokyo on a cargo plane.
Alison Brown: well, given that Ben Ryan was telling us a story, how they had to ride coach, they might actually be more comfortable in cargo.
Those are some big guys on that rugby team.
Jill Jaracz: That is exactly what I thought like. They probably are like leg room. We’ve got all the leg room in the world. ,
Alison Brown: you know, no pillows, no, you know, the no air conditioning, but we have leg room.
Jill Jaracz: the IOC also made a decision to make team sport or to give team sports more roster flexibility.
So, uh, in a lot of sports like football, handball, hockey, rugby, and water polo, if they ever had to use an alternate, it was a permanent replacement, but now they have flexibility to move alternates in and out. And I [00:56:00] think that’s just because of the situation, we don’t know what will happen. So teams have been given a little bit more flexibility there.
And we’ll close up with bad news because why not castor Semenya is not going to be able to compete at Tokyo this year. She had been champion for at Rio in the 800 meters. Then the world athletics association put on a whole bunch of measures saying that women could have women in the specific races that she ran could only have so much testosterone in their body.
She could, she had the option to take medicine to bring down that level of testosterone, but she did not want to because who knows what that would do to your body too. And so she tried to qualify for Tokyo in the 5,000 meters, because that was a distance that she would be legally allowed to legally in the world athletics sense of the word allowed to compete in, but she did not make qualifying Tokyo times for [00:57:00] that.
Alison Brown: And she is not the only runner who’s been hit with this high, natural testosterone band. I know there were two other Namibian runners that have also been banned because of their high, natural testosterone. So this battle is nowhere near over. Unfortunately, we’re gonna be talking about this in world athletics for a long time,
Jill Jaracz: right.
And Simonia said that she’ll still compete the Olympics. Aren’t the end all be all for her. Uh, she likes having fun. She likes running cuz it’s a lot of fun for her. So she just wants to be on the track for a long time. And that’s what she’s going to keep working on. Then, uh, if you’re in the us, you probably are interested in the Shak Richardson story.
Uh, Shak pretty much blew away the field in the hundred meter dash and is one of the fastest women in the world. Won the [00:58:00] event and then, uh, tested positive for marijuana use and that, and the
Alison Brown: us Olympic trials.
Jill Jaracz: Yes. And that has unleashed a storm of controversy. I, I will say that Sheary because people were, were saying a, why is marijuana Bann in the first place, but the world anti-doping agency allows a little bit of THC in your system.
So like you could take CBD oil and stuff, but basically it was kind of pretty much Shakira used marijuana on the day of competition and you can debate about marijuana and what it can do for you. It probably depends on the strain and how it interacts with your body. So it could very well have been a performing enhancing experience for her.
We don’t know for sure, but it, it was above the water limit. So there was a little window of hope because she got a one month suspension. And that suspension would [00:59:00] end before the relay started in Tokyo, but USA track and field has decided not to include it. Her on the roster. Do you have thoughts?
Alison Brown: Of course I have thoughts.
Jill Jaracz: what are your thoughts?
Alison Brown: Okay. So here are our thoughts. First of all, she, Carrie Richardson has been handling this situation with a lot of grace.
Jill Jaracz: Oh
Alison Brown: yes. In a lot of class.
Jill Jaracz: Yes.
Alison Brown: And I wanna say good on you. You’re handling it much better than a lot of other people who are speaking for you.
Jill Jaracz: Mm-hmm
Alison Brown: second. We can debate all we want.
Whether pot should be banned or not banned, you know, supporters of pot use, go on and on about how it’s great for pain relief. It is great for anxiety and it it’s this miracle drug. And if it is, then it affects your body and competition. There are many, many, many, many drugs that are legal, that are still banned.
There are many pain medications that are [01:00:00] banned, even though they are legal, they are prescription medications. There are asthma medications that are banned. So legality is not an argument for whether a drug should be on the band list or not. The argument is, does it affect their performance? And clearly pot can affect your performance, whether it should be on or off.
That list is a separate argument. So Sheary broke the rules. End of discussion. If you wanna talk, take this discussion to change the rules, separate argument. She broke the rules. She took the punishment, and I think everybody needs to remember that just cuz it’s legal in such and such state. Nevermind.
Doesn’t make it legal around the world.
Jill Jaracz: Mm-hmm
Alison Brown: these are international rules and that’s not the deciding factor.
Jill Jaracz: Very well said. I think I do feel I’ve I feel a lot of empathy for Sheary cuz you’re [01:01:00] absolutely right. She handled this with such grace and has been very open about it and, and basically said I’m human and she’s young.
She’s 21. We’re a little past 21, but we know enough that when you’re that age and well, even now people make some stupid mistakes sometimes and she made us mistake and just happened to make it on a stage that where she has a lot of visibility. So I think she’s handled it as well as she can. I bet she’s, I mean, obviously extremely disappointed, but has been very poised and very graceful about the whole situation she’s not done.
Of course. You know, because as every athlete who goes through a suspension, you’re allowed to come back unless you’re permanently banned, so she’ll be back and she’ll, she said she’ll. She’s ready, getting ready for the world championships next year, which are gonna be in the United States. So track
Alison Brown: as the trials.
Jill Jaracz: Exactly. Paris is only three years away. [01:02:00] She could have a very long career ahead of her and a very successful one, which I hope because she’s got so much talent.
Alison Brown: And on the flip side, the us ATF screwed up by not putting her on the relays.
Jill Jaracz: Do you think? I mean,
Alison Brown: yes, I do. Okay. Because she did not fight this ban, you know, mm-hmm she said I screwed up, she put her hand up and said, yep.
I screwed up. I take my punishment. You’ve already taken away her ability to be named the fastest woman on earth. Let’s reward athletes who stand up, take responsibility and act with such grace in class. And don’t try and end undermine the doping system.
Jill Jaracz: Because my, my thought is that U S a TF made the decision kind of on a technicality, because if she doped during the, if, if relays were chosen based on performance at the trials and your performance [01:03:00] at the trials is disqualified.
Does that result count? so how do we choose? Do we choose somebody who got themselves disqualified for the trials and make that sort of statement or do we choose the talent and make that sort of statement? So it’s, it’s a good it’s it’s I think it was a very hard decision to make. I was, I was very surprised that they didn’t take her.
Alison Brown: The re the reason I say they made a mistake is because there’s been a lot of discussion lately, rela they’ve they’ve lumped together, the Chiari Richardson story, the Castro Armenia, and the other distance running, lowering, you know, forcing them to lower their testosterone, the banning of the new swim caps that have been designed for natural hair.
Jill Jaracz: Oh,
Alison Brown: so we lumped all this. We lumped all this together as the IOC is racist
Jill Jaracz: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and the S a TF could have nipped that story in the bud by naming her to the relays and taken that element off the [01:04:00] table and saying, yes, she broke a rule. Yes, we recognize. She made a mistake and we’re not gonna overly punish her for that mistake.
Theme Music: Hmm.
Alison Brown: So let’s pull that out. So at least you turn it around, but now people who generally are not terribly Olympic fans are lumping all these things together to create a racist narrative.
Theme Music: Hmm.
Alison Brown: And the, and that Simone Biles is being punished for being too good. They’ve thrown that in the mix and that Gwen and Barry is being punished for her podium protest at the trials.
So let’s make everything that happens to any African American or, uh, black athlete around the world. Evidence that the IOC is racist.
Jill Jaracz: Hmm.
Alison Brown: So the TF kind of, HTF kind of missed a chance to pull a plug on that.
Jill Jaracz: Yeah.
Alison Brown: And let me just say, it’s not like the IOC doesn’t have a history of racism.
Jill Jaracz: Very true. [01:05:00] Very very
Alison Brown: true.
So come on. You’re, you’re shooting yourself in the foot with a lot of these decisions that whether they are racist or not, clearly, some of them are, but even when they’re not, they look it mm-hmm and that’s just dumb, dumb,
Jill Jaracz: right. And if we learn
Alison Brown: dumb,
Jill Jaracz: do you got anything happy to go out of?
Alison Brown: It is two weeks to Tokyo.
Jill Jaracz: Excellent.
Alison Brown: And I am red, deep.
Jill Jaracz: Excellent. I like that. All right. Well, that’s gonna do it for this week. Let us know what you think about the state of women’s gymnastics.
Alison Brown: Email us at flame alive pod, gmail.com. Call or text us at (208) 352-6348. That’s 2 0 8, flame it we’re flame alive pod on Twitter and Insta and keep the flame alive podcast group on Facebook.
Jill Jaracz: Join us next time for our interview with shooter Tim Sherry, as we go out to music by mercury sunset. Thank you so much for listening and until next time, [01:06:00] keep the flame alive.[01:07:00]
Alison Brown: So I was a Nadia [01:08:00] [01:09:00] [01:10:00] baby.

