Film Buff Fran is back for another edition of Movie Club! On this episode we discuss Foxcatcher, the 2014 film based on the true story of Olympic wrestlers Dave and Mark Schultz and their involvement with multimillionaire John E. du Pont, whose great-great grandfather founded the DuPont chemical and materials company
Here’s a little bit about John E. du Pont:
A sports enthusiast, du Pont tried to become a modern pentathlete. When that didn’t work out, he became interested in wrestling and started his own team. He recruited two-time Olympian Mark Schultz, and eventually Mark’s brother Dave to Foxcatcher Farm, his estate, which du Pont hoped would become the national training center for wrestling.
The Schulz brothers both won gold medals in freestyle wrestling at LA 1984, and Mark also competed at Seoul 1988. At Foxcatcher, they coached and trained, and Mark hoped to make a comeback at Atlanta 1996.
Unfortunately, du Pont’s behavior becomes increasingly erratic, and the story ends tragically for Dave Schultz. Steve Carell stars as the eccentric du Pont, Channing Tatum plays Mark Schultz, and Mark Ruffalo plays Dave Schultz in this highly-acclaimed film.
Check out the trailer:
Did we think as highly of it?
In our conversation, we also talk about the book that inspired this movie. If you missed our book club conversation, find it here.
What are our TKFLASTANIs up to this week? We’ve got news from:
Due to the Memorial Day holiday in the U.S., we’re having a shorter show this week; however, the news from Tokyo 2020 has been the same: More calls for cancellation while the Organizing Committee goes full steam ahead. That said, Japan’s vaccination rate continues to climb — slowly, but it’s definitely increasing. Will that upward movement be too little, too late? Wait….do we have a vaxnovella on our hands??
Thanks so much for listening, and until next time, keep the flame alive!
Note: Links to products may be affiliate links. We may earn commissions through purchases made through them.
TRANSCRIPT
Note: This is an uncorrected machine-generated transcript and may contain errors. Please check its accuracy against the audio. Do not quote from the transcript; use the audio as the record of note.
190-Movie Club – Foxcatcher
Alison Brown: [00:00:00] If he had taken one of the stuffed birds, you know, that had gotten closeups. If he had taken the book, if he had taken the TV, but this blue end table and I’m thinking, does he just like that color
Theme Music
Jill Jaracz: Hello, fans of shook Stan and welcome to another episode of keep the flame alive. The podcast, four fans of the Olympics and Paralympics. I am your host. Jill. Jarris joined as always by my lovely co-host Allison brown, Allison. Hello, how are you today?
Alison Brown: I am unpacking all my white clothes. Since now. We are allowed to wear white clothes [00:01:00] after labor day.
Jill Jaracz: I mean, after Memorial day I do not allow myself to wear very many white clothes because they do not stay white for very long.
Alison Brown: Yes, and I will be breaking out the barbecue and various and sundry buntings of red, white, and blue
Jill Jaracz: sounds good. You know what, for me, this weekend is Indianapolis 500 weekend and as a native Hoosier, the race runs thick in my blood.
Alison Brown: As does the diesel fumes ,
Foxcatcher discussion with Film Buff Fran
Jill Jaracz: but it’s also a good weekend. You know, it’s also like, like the traditional traditional, even though dates kept getting pushed forward, the traditional start of the summer movie season. And so we are having movie club today. Film club Fran is back to discuss a Fox catcher. The movie based on the book that we read for our most recent book club, the, uh, Mark Schultz story of how, uh, John DuPont, uh, murdered [00:02:00] his brother, Dave.
And, uh, it stars Steve Corll as John DuPont and chaning Tatum as Mark Schultz and mark Ruffo as Dave Schultz, take LL listen to our conversation
Alison Brown: movie club.
Jill Jaracz: Fran. Welcome back. We’re talking Fox catcher. What do you have for us?
Film Buff Fran: Well, today we are going to talk about Fox catcher, which came out in 2014 and it stars Steve corral as John DuPont and eccentric, uh, millionaire and Channing Tatum and mark Ruffo.
Are a pair of brothers who are wrestlers. It is based on a true story of the two brothers who, um, are Olympians they’re gold medalists, uh, from Los Angeles in 1984 in freestyle wrestling. And it’s the story of how these two brothers became associated with John DuPont, who is a millionaire. So [00:03:00] spoiler alert, um, unfortunately, you know, after the two brothers associated with Mr.
DuPont in the end, Mr. DuPont ended up killing. Dave Schultz, which is the older brother in front of his wife and a security person, uh, on the property. And he ended up going to prison, uh, for the crime. So in the beginning, you know, the thing that struck me is the, the tone of the movie was very somber and very serious, very slow.
It’s not the kind of movie that I usually enjoy watching. I, I really like something that has a little faster pace. This was very, it felt very calculated. It felt very, uh, slow moving plotting through actually. So it was actually a little tough to watch. I felt like, and I didn’t quite understand. I, I did not try to really.[00:04:00]
The storyline beforehand. I just wanted to watch it evolve on the screen. So I didn’t really know much about anything that was going to happen. So I was just kinda waiting for, you know, some eventual. You know, big circumstance that happened between them. Cause I knew something big happened. I think the actors did a wonderful job, uh, portraying these characters.
However, you know, I, I didn’t like anybody , you know, they weren’t really likable people really.
Jill Jaracz: So I, I think it’s interesting that you. It felt calculated because that, to me, the director kind of got John DuPont who was calculating all these moves along the way and had that tone throughout the movie.
Theme Music: Mm-hmm
Jill Jaracz: that, that I thought was kind of inter interesting. So I saw it in the theater when it came out and didn’t know a ton about Mark Schultz and Dave Schultz. [00:05:00] And then we read the book and I watched it again. It. , it was interesting to have the knowledge of the book with me because it’s almost part of the problem because mark Schultz’s book is not very good.
Mm
Alison Brown: it’s very, you know, what we talked about in book club is how skewed mark Schultz’s perspective was.
Film Buff Fran: Okay.
Alison Brown: And one of the things that I complained about in that book is I would really have liked a third party view.
Film Buff Fran: Mm.
Alison Brown: And the way this movie is constructed, even though. is the central figure in the movie.
It is more of a third party view.
Film Buff Fran: Mm-hmm mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and I definitely felt like I was getting in a strange way, a much more complete picture
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and yet I wondered how anyone could know what the heck was going on. If you hadn’t read the book, because there were so many missing pizzas. The way this movie unfolded, it was almost like a [00:06:00] series of vignettes,
Film Buff Fran: right?
Mm-hmm right.
Alison Brown: It was just like snapshots. And even they did like a fade to black, right. Between sections. And I would have been confused. I remember, as I was watching it, I was thinking to myself. Okay. So in the book, this is where we are. But what you mentioned about the acting, the physicality of all three of the main actors mm-hmm was so good when chaning tain first appears on the screen and he has that almost Neer Alish stance and walk
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and method of eating was brilliant.
And, and mark R’s sort of gentle. Yet still hoing quality to him. No pun intended to see, also play the whole mm-hmm . And then that, you know that as you said, the very calculating movements of Steve corral,
Film Buff Fran: right.
Alison Brown: Was I think what made me feel like I was getting a, a fuller picture of the story, but I didn’t know what the heck was going on.
And I read the book,
Film Buff Fran: but it’s, it’s unfortunate because, [00:07:00] and I don’t know if, if mark goes into this in his book, You know, when you first meet mark in this movie, like you said, he’s very quiet. Doesn’t talk that much. Neanderthal just shows things through his movements, you know, and doesn’t really talk that much.
So then I was thinking to myself, okay, is he slow? Is he autistic? You know, what, who is this person? And it, it almost seemed like he was very simple. But then, you know, you learn that he went to college and I’m like, okay, well he went to college. And then when I started doing some research online and I was reading some clips of, of things that he said, his clips were very articulate.
So I’m like, okay, well, this doesn’t seem like the same person that was portrayed in the movie.
Alison Brown: I got that impression as well. I thought they portrayed him as. Intellectually disabled in some way,
Film Buff Fran: correct? [00:08:00] Correct. Yeah. That’s how I felt. I’m like, is this, you know, you know, it, it just seemed like that because it seemed like also that Dave was always the protector, you know, he always felt like he had to protect his brother and do things for him.
And I was thinking, well, why isn’t he doing things for himself? I mean, he was a, an Olympic champion. Yeah, he did that one talk in front of the kids in the beginning of the movie, but he didn’t seem thrilled to do it. So, you know, was he down on his luck? Was he, you know, did he have no skills? You know, why, why wasn’t he doing something other than, you know, sitting in his.
Second floor, apartment eating day, old food, like by himself. I,
Jill Jaracz: I think it’s a combination of all of that. Cuz one of the things in the book seemed to be that he didn’t have very many friends, so he shuttled back and forth between parents a lot. Mm-hmm growing up. And then when he was a competitor, he just had this focus on [00:09:00] himself kind of, and did not want to necessarily get to know his teammates and.
I think that was part of the, the book that you got, the sense that he was just kind of, I am an island kind of guy, and I think what in the movie, it makes it look like, oh, he’s living in his brother’s shadow, which is kind of part of it.
Film Buff Fran: Hmm.
Jill Jaracz: And then also he’s very poor because wrestling doesn’t pay anything.
Film Buff Fran: Right.
Jill Jaracz: And, and then I think for him, that was it like, didn’t think much beyond. What am I gonna do when I’m done with my competitive athletic career?
Film Buff Fran: Mm-hmm ,
Jill Jaracz: you know, maybe he figured he’d go on and coach, but there just doesn’t seem to be much to him, right. Necessarily personality wise. Right. You know, he plays his, his game boy, and that’s probably about it and watch this TV.
Film Buff Fran: And it was very strange how, you know, all of a sudden, like he gets this phone [00:10:00] call from John DuPont about wanting to meet him. And I’m like, this is just very strange, you know, it almost felt avant garde, you know, how he gets in this helicopter and, and I’m just like, well, where did he start out from? And then I had to, I Googled where his brother was working and I’m like, okay, they’re in Massachusetts.
Okay. And then I’m like, well, why did he take a plane? To Pennsylvania and then a helicopter.
Alison Brown: Well, in, in reality, he was in California.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, he was in California. So,
Jill Jaracz: so if you wanna talk about like factual, like Fox catcher is just above gold in what’s actually true in this movie because they compress the timelines.
So much.
Film Buff Fran: Yes. That’s
Jill Jaracz: I
Film Buff Fran: noticed
Jill Jaracz: and things did not happen exactly. When it looks like in the movie. And part of the issue of kind of Fox catcher. The book is that mark and Dave were never at Fox catcher [00:11:00] farms at the same time.
Film Buff Fran: Oh really?
Jill Jaracz: So they had to put them together.
Film Buff Fran: Oh,
Jill Jaracz: that’s the heightened, the plot of the movie.
So of course, mark did not know what was going on while Dave was there necessarily. So
Film Buff Fran: that would shock. Yeah. Cause that did not. That was definitely not portrayed the same way in the movie.
Alison Brown: No, in the movie, it almost felt like the reason for the murder is because Dave gets in between John and Mark’s.
Friendship.
Film Buff Fran: Right? Right.
Alison Brown: Like that’s the motivation for the murder. Whereas in the book, the only motivation that mark talks about is that Dave was going to leave the farm.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, interesting.
Alison Brown: So it’s a very different presentation of why the murder. Happened.
Film Buff Fran: Right. And I think online when I was trying to research it and see like legitimately, like, was there any other [00:12:00] resources on it?
And they said they really don’t know exactly why. He did what he did that is really interesting that they weren’t together at the same time. Because one of the things I was curious about was, you know, mark was there at the beginning training with DuPont and the other, uh, wrestlers. And then Dave did not wanna go train at the facility and he wanted to stay where he was with his family.
And then all of a sudden he showed up. And I was like, well, why, you know, he was so emphatic about not wanting to be there. And then all of a sudden he showed up and he wanted to participate. So that was just kind of a weird, like all of a sudden his whole family moved out to Fox catcher when, before he would never wanna do that.
So I just thought that was just kind of a weird change to the movie.
Jill Jaracz: It could have been that one of his, his coaching gig ended and he needed a job and Fox Keer farms was always there for him.
Film Buff Fran: Okay. That would make,
Jill Jaracz: you [00:13:00] know, when you have a family.
Film Buff Fran: Sure.
Jill Jaracz: John, DuPont’s gonna offer you a ton of money. Sure.
He’s already made a name for himself in the wrestling world as his huge benefactor.
Film Buff Fran: Mm-hmm.
Jill Jaracz: So you get a place to live, you get to train, you get great facilities, right? You get, you know, it’s, it’s worth going to, and he was there for years too. That’s the other thing that it doesn’t really seem because, cause the timeline was so compressed,
Film Buff Fran: right?
Jill Jaracz: You don’t necessarily see all the years and Dave was going to make a comeback in wrestling and you don’t see that really either.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, that’s interesting.
Alison Brown: Right. So the, the other question of the time compression is when, so mark left Fox catcher at the very end of 1988. And Dave comes to Fox catcher in 89.
The murder doesn’t happen until 96
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm .
Alison Brown: So his children. We’re very, very young when he moved to [00:14:00] Pennsylvania. So in the movie, mark ruffs, Dave Schult says my kids are in school. I don’t wanna move them. Well, they weren’t. Oh, they weren’t really in school until they went to Pennsylvania. So
Film Buff Fran: interesting.
Alison Brown: Yeah. I mean, you would have to go through a whole, multiple chapters of Dave was a coach at Stanford and he had a contract and he had committed and he and Nancy had just gotten married and he didn’t want so all of the, and he had always lived in California. Hmm. So didn’t wanna move. But the, the movie makes it seem like all of these events happen within maybe an 18 month.
Mm
Film Buff Fran: right, right. Period.
Alison Brown: Two years that much, when really it was more like close to 10 years.
Film Buff Fran: Right. It just seemed very weird, like the whole scenario of, you know, mark with John, and you can see that, you know, John, they portrayed John DuPont as this eccentric, very wealthy person [00:15:00] with just weird kind of.
Affect and just, you could tell he just was not a well liked person and, you know, they, they made a point to, to talk about how, you know, the only person that was his friend when he was young, was this other, the chauffeur’s kid. And he, he found out later that his mother had paid him to be his friend. And, and I mean, the way you know, that he portrayed him, you could see why he was just a weird.
I don’t know how, how true to life he was, but he just seemed very, very odd. And then the question I had too, and the way it was portrayed in the movie, there almost seemed to be a little bit of a sexual tension between mark and John and they didn’t overtly, you know, do anything sexual, but it just seemed.
You just kinda had that feeling like was there this kind of almost sexual tension in the [00:16:00] room between them, you know, there was that odd scene where, uh, John showed up. And asked mark to wrestle. And it was like middle of the night and they’re in the, the wrestling room in the dark going through moves.
And you’re just going, you know, what the heck, you know, this is just really weird.
Jill Jaracz: yeah. And you, you may have seen that in the research you did, because it’s one thing that mark. Didn’t like he, there were times where he really liked the movie then times where he really didn’t like the movie
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Jill Jaracz: and he seemed to flip back and forth on a dime too.
And he did not like the sexual undertones mm-hmm of a possible relationship between him and, and Deon.
Film Buff Fran: And it was odd too, because I was looking into just research on the people and it, it came up that John DuPont was married.
Jill Jaracz: Yeah. For a little while. Very short marriage.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, okay. So they didn’t show the wife at all.
And then mark [00:17:00] also had children and was married. So I don’t know if that was just at way after this or was it during this time, but they didn’t portray any kind of family life. Other than Dave,
Alison Brown: there was a girlfriend of Mark’s during this time, but his marriage happened after he left Fox catcher. Okay.
Jill Jaracz: and John DuPont’s marriage was very, very short.
Film Buff Fran: Huh.
Jill Jaracz: And his wife basically left because she felt her life was in danger.
Film Buff Fran: Huh? I wonder why. Well, his mother didn’t seem very loving
Alison Brown: I, I felt like they kind of put her in as a character as this very offhand. Trope of the cold mother
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: to explain the crazy son.
Film Buff Fran: Yeah, it was too bad. Cuz you just saw this classic. Oh my mom never gave me any attention and love and I’m [00:18:00] I just wanted to prove myself to her and uh, but I hate her at the same time.
Alison Brown: Right. And, and she calls breasting a low sport. Oh, that was
Film Buff Fran: so bad.
Alison Brown: Me involved in such a low sport, John,
Film Buff Fran: but they, but it was interesting cuz all the research and, and in the movie it kinda. Well, it sort of shows this too a little bit, but it said that he really didn’t go kind of a little bit more wacko until after she passed.
so they said that he had some men, they believed he had some mental illness, but it really was only when she passed away that he started to be even really more, you know, showing signs of mental breakdown.
Alison Brown: So almost that she kept him in check that she was a balancing force. Mm-hmm rather than the instigating force mm-hmm of his illness.
Is often the case. So it it’s that horrible trope of moms cause the mental illness, when in fact it’s usually the other way around that, they’re the ones keeping it together.
Film Buff Fran: They kind of alluded [00:19:00] to what would happen in the end, because they were always showing him like, like doing military moves and having guns and shooting guns with the police force and the whole, the weird thing where they got that big arm
Alison Brown: really got a tank.
Film Buff Fran: He did get a tank
Alison Brown: that was, that was true. That he had a tank with a mounted machine gun.
Film Buff Fran: Wow.
Jill Jaracz: And he would have the police on. A state to train. That was another aspect they’d go to there, to, to practice on the shooting range.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, wow. Yeah. That would make more sense if they kind of flesh that out a little bit more.
Alison Brown: Yeah. I wanna go back to the sexual tension because the way this movie is structured, it feels like Mark’s reaction to this somewhat cover. Homosexual certainly presented from John is the reason he wants to leave Fox catcher. And without that sexual tension, there’s no reason for their relationship to have fallen [00:20:00] apart, which I thought was again, kind of a lazy shorthand in this movie.
Film Buff Fran: Well, I don’t, I didn’t didn’t understand. So he went to the championships, then he, he didn’t do so well. And then he ate like crazy. In frustration. That’s how I took it. And then his brother realized what he had done and kind of got, brought him back from the edge to, you know, eventually win and do really well.
And then there was that. Awkward 10 scene where John wanted to go in to see what was going on with mark and Dave wouldn’t let him come. And mark had this really weird glaring, you know, zoned out, look on his face and, and I’m like, well, it was it all. Just mark resented John for showing him all the drugs and getting him involved and all this, you know, stuff that kind of detracted him.
His sport or was it more like you said, more of the [00:21:00] sexual side of things and he just felt super uncomfortable. I mean, there was also the scene where John flat out, you know, back hands, him, you know, in front of the other players. So was there more physical abuse by John to mark? And he just kind of had enough, but it, it felt very odd that all of a sudden mark just shut down and said, I’m.
So that part of the movie I thought was kind of more vague than it should be.
Jill Jaracz: Right. And it’s hard to understand coming into watching this wrestling tournament, if you don’t know what’s going on. So that was the Olympic trials and to. Get your spot on the Olympic team. And this happens today too. You have to win the best two out of three matches.
So mark loses his first one and, and then he gets all frustrated and furious and he eats all of room service. And then Dave is like, no, no, you still got a chance. We gotta get you [00:22:00] back. And he still had to weigh in. So of course, it’s time for the, the infamous cutting scene to which I. Puked myself. , it’s just, I’m sorry, I can’t watch that stuff.
So he cut and came down and made the, the Olympics. But I know in the book, this is for the soul Olympics. If I remember it correctly, he was tired of, DuPont’s just kind of layers of abuse directed at him, and it may have just been subtle abuse, but he basically threw his matches in, in soul. Because he didn’t want to give John DuPont the satisfaction of having an Olympic gold medal.
On his squad.
Film Buff Fran: Interesting.
Alison Brown: Well, that’s how mark presented in his book,
Jill Jaracz: right? Exactly.
Film Buff Fran: That’s a spin on why he did so poorly. Right.
Mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and it definitely seemed like the apologist version of what happened in Seoul. I mean, considering that even mark admits that in the run up to soul, he was [00:23:00] doing cocaine.
He was not training the way he should have been. Um, the whole incident of the, what happened at the Olympic trials and him having to cut it last minute. He did include that in the book. So isn’t it easy to have the excuse
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and they, they do somewhat present it in the movie where, where DuPont is.
His corner at soul and he looks at him, uh, uh, mark looks at at DuPont and just kind of stops trying.
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm,
Alison Brown: like, I can’t do this. And the, in the, in the movie they presented as he comes home from soul and leaves immediately.
Film Buff Fran: Right, right, right. So in the book, how long did it take for him to leave?
Alison Brown: Not long.
I mean, a couple of months.
Film Buff Fran: Okay.
Alison Brown: It wasn’t long. It definitely was from soul, kind of got his bearings figured out what he was gonna do next, got a job in Utah and left.
Jill Jaracz: Little tiny details there. The guy who was weighing [00:24:00] him in at the us Olympic trials was Mark Schultz. Oh, that was his cameo in the, in the film.
Yeah, exactly. Then I also wanted to know maybe he had been there long enough, but remember how he, you show up at a mansion and you’ve got a car full of stuff. And you leave said mansion in which you are living in a fully furnished chalet and you leave with a moving truck. Did he walk off with a bunch of John DuPont’s furniture?
That’s what I really wanted to know. What did
Alison Brown: he, well, he did walk out with that table and he definitely did not come in with that table. Like why out of all the items they could have shown Chan Tatum carrying it was this Royal. End table. Did that make an appearance somewhere else in the, maybe there’s a cult scene where that end table has some purpose, but it was such an odd object to be holding.
Like if he had taken one of the stuffed birds, you know, that had gotten [00:25:00] closeups. If he had taken the book, if he had taken the TV, but this blue end table I’m thinking, does he just like that color? What
Jill Jaracz: his Fox catcher blue. Why would you have it remind you of that
Alison Brown: place? Well, right. It was such an odd item to show him carrying out and, and such a definite choice.
Like it wasn’t random. It wasn’t like they showed him carrying a whole bunch of things.
Film Buff Fran: Interesting. I was geeking out through most of the movie at, uh, Anthony, Michael Hall making an appearance free I was like, oh my gosh, is that Anthony Michael Hall? And then I wanted to see more of him. And then he wasn’t in a lot of the movie.
Alison Brown: No. And, and speaking of cameos, us wrestler, Bruce Baumgartner. Makes an appearance early on. He is one of the USA wrestling officials.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, neat.
Alison Brown: And he actually mark RLO as Dave Schult calls him Bruce. So it, it [00:26:00] highlights that a little bit. So I thought that was interesting that many American wrestlers and people involved in the story were involved in this movie.
Jill Jaracz: it. It’s also interesting that Baumgartner was in the movie and did some of the wrestling coaching prep for the movie because he had been invited to Fox catcher farms and did not go because he was really creeped out by John DuPont.
Film Buff Fran: And you wonder how many people were invited and had the same feeling and then just opted not to train there just because of that.
Alison Brown: When we were going through the book and we were talking to Jason Bryant about it. One of the things he talked about as just being part of the zeitgeist of that time was everybody knew John DuPont was creepy, but wrestlers had no place to go
Film Buff Fran: Hmm.
Alison Brown: And had no money and had no facilities. And colleges were cutting programs left and right.[00:27:00]
So what are you gonna do?
Film Buff Fran: Right.
Alison Brown: You’re gonna bite your tongue and deal with creepy John DuPont.
Jill Jaracz: right. And if you’re low enough on the totem pole, you don’t even really deal with him. He might show up once a week or whatever, or show up to practice. And he’s not gonna pick up on you. Pick on you necessarily.
Alison Brown: I wanna go back to something that you said earlier, Fran, about not liking anybody. And I’m, I’m curious as to why you didn’t like Dave.
Film Buff Fran: You know what? I don’t know. It, he just, I don’t know. Maybe it just, I don’t think they ever focused enough on his character. He just was very peripheral to me. You know, in the beginning he was just the bigger brother, you know, and then, you know, mark went out on his own, but then he showed back up, but then he was just kind of more an ancillary character, but then he kind of came to the forefront.
Toward the middle and end of the storyline, but I don’t know. I just didn’t, [00:28:00] I just didn’t feel very vested in him as a character.
Jill Jaracz: And, and I think that’s part of the problem is that the movie is based on Mark’s book and mark wasn’t there and there could have been, he loved his brother and he constantly said that in the book.
I love my brother. I love my brother, but he also could have been feeling a second fiddle. Everybody in the wrestling world loved Dave. And that’s kind of what I got from this movie is that just in little tiny touches where he’d say Hey to somebody, or just talk to a whole bunch of people here and there that he liked, he, he was just beloved, but it’s really hard when the source material is the main role in the movie.
But the event that the movie is supposed to be about, isn’t about the main actor. Mm. and that’s the same problem with the book, especially since mark wasn’t there at the time.
Film Buff Fran: Right.
Jill Jaracz: He didn’t, you know, when, when you have a book that is supposed to be about Dave Schultz’s murder, but it’s written [00:29:00] from somebody’s point of view who wasn’t there and, and who is, and you can say that about a third party too, but it’s written as a first person book.
Hmm. So I think that for me, that’s one of the issues with the movie, just because I think the source material doesn’t provide. They needed. And even though the director looked at other things and interviewed other people to get a more fleshed out story, I, I still think that what you’re dealing with is a lead character.
Who’s not particularly interesting,
Film Buff Fran: correct.
Jill Jaracz: And an event that doesn’t happen to the main character,
Film Buff Fran: correct?
Alison Brown: I thought a brilliant moment. Very small is that between mark and Dave’s wife, Nancy in the hotel. where they have that little argument about how Nancy spoke to John DuPont. And from what we have read since the relationship between mark and Nancy number one was never very good.
And since Dave’s [00:30:00] murder has been very strained. Hmm. And I thought that was just an interesting little tell that they put in to acknowledge because Nancy was very involved in the movie. and in fact, the glasses that mark ruffle wears are Dave Schults, actual glasses.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, wow.
Alison Brown: So I think that little argument and giving Nancy a moment that doesn’t seem to make sense makes sense.
If you recognize that Nancy and Mark’s relationship now is very.
Film Buff Fran: Well, and that kind of makes sense. If you go back to their backstory as children, you know, having divorced parents moving around a lot, they only had each other. So of course, anyone who’s going to pull Dave away from mark I E you know, his wife, he’s going to feel some kind of animosity towards her.
So that kind of makes sense. [00:31:00] Maybe I, you know, I almost felt like mark almost kind of resented what Dave had. You know, he had that loving family, he had those children, he had something to hold onto where mark just seemed very adrift. You know, he just didn’t seem like he was comfortable. Wasn’t happy with his life.
It seemed like he was comfortable and happy training and being with the crew at Fox catch. Doing doing the wrestling, but for the most part, he, mark just seemed like a very sad, sad character
Jill Jaracz: until he got those frosted tips.
Alison Brown: can we talk or his Jill texted to me his cocaine hair.
Film Buff Fran: Yes. And I thought it was very odd that an Olympic athlete in training.
For a major event, would all of a sudden like choose to do drugs? [00:32:00] Cause I’m like, wasn’t there drug testing. I mean, how,
Alison Brown: yeah.
Film Buff Fran: I mean, how did he think that this was going to end up? You know, it just seemed very odd that he would make that choice. He could have easily said no
Alison Brown: in the. Mark, definitely glosses over the cocaine use third party reporting and stories were that his cocaine use was much more serious
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: than what he included in the book.
And I guess they sort of glossed over it in the movie because of that. I mean, the, the movie makers are hampered as Joe was saying by their source material. I mean, they can bring in external things, but. I guess getting frosted tips is like the worldwide signifier. If I have a drug problem, sort of like when girls get the black eyeliner, it’s like, oh, they’re they they’ve gone bad.
If boys get frosted tips, they’re either joined a [00:33:00] boy band or taking too much cocaine
Film Buff Fran: can . Yeah, the, that was, it was just such an odd. Addition, you know, I know they had to address it in some capacity, but it just, it just didn’t make sense to me that a premier athlete, you know, still in his prime, still wanting, still having those goals that a competitor has, would not throw it away, but, you know, go down a path that could potentially, you know, derail him forever.
Alison Brown: Speaking of derailed, what the ending made no sense. I mean, I understand the context of the ending because we read the book, but as a movie, it was the most unsatisfying ending.
Film Buff Fran: Oh, completely. I wanted a trial. I wanted to see what happened afterwards. I wanted to see if like Nancy sued for, for money and you know what happened?
Jill Jaracz: Yeah. We get his one [00:34:00] marks, one MMA fight and yeah. And, and what we Don. Also don’t see, because of a compressed timeline is that there was a big standoff. I mean, John Deon hold up, hold up in his, his mansion for days.
Film Buff Fran: I mean, that would be more compelling to watch actually. Mm-hmm so I don’t know why they decided to just have him like, look like he was like a weird, lost plumber.
in the bowels of a part of his mansion. Instead of the standoff, cuz that would’ve made more sense. You know, when I read that online afterwards, I was like, oh, well that’s a more plausible ending. Some, you know, I was talking to my husband about it and I’m like, well he was a millionaire. I mean, you know,
Alison Brown: a tank
Film Buff Fran: with a tank I’m like, of course.
I mean, well, first of all, it was interesting because of, of course his lawyers pleaded Insa. At his trial and you know, so I was kind of half joking, half serious in the car with, uh, my husband today [00:35:00] saying, well, of course he was insane. Why would a millionaire kill somebody in broad daylight, you know, in front of witnesses, you know, when he could have had someone else do it for him.
And then afterwards, Know, he could have disappeared so it just was a very odd situation, but I guess that would, that kind of encapsulated who John DuPont was, he was odd. He was weird. You didn’t know what was going on in his mind. I guess he carried weaponry a lot. I mean, I think there was an episode I read about where he actually accosted another wrestler with a firearm.
Previous to that episode and the wrestler, I guess, got him to put the gun away and AB Abed the situation. So I, I don’t think that that was the first time he pulled a gun on someone at Fox catcher.
Alison Brown: And once again, we get a transformational hairdo from Channing Tatum. somehow, I guess he has the redemptive [00:36:00] bald head now.
At the end. I, I didn’t understand any of that ending sequence where they show him going into the MMA fight with the shaved head. Mm. Again, it was so definitive. I mean, there was nothing accidental about using that story and, and that physicality, and yet it made no sense.
Film Buff Fran: It didn’t make any sense.
Jill Jaracz: I kind of wonder what the director’s cut is like.
Film Buff Fran: Hmm.
Alison Brown: It was originally four hours long.
Film Buff Fran: No, not gonna watch. No way you couldn’t pay me. I’d rather watch more of gold
Alison Brown: well, at least there, we got song and dance, man.
Film Buff Fran: And, and the other side of the mountain part two
Alison Brown: You know, what I thought was so interesting was how unattractive both chaning Tatum and mark Ruffo were in this movie, right? Both were very at attract. I mean, especially Chan chaning Tatum. I happened to be a mark RLO fan. How truly attractive they [00:37:00] are and charismatic.
Film Buff Fran: Right.
Alison Brown: And in this movie, they’re not,
Film Buff Fran: they’re very flat, very flat effects.
And I, in pictures, looking at pictures of the Schults brothers, they were more good looking. I felt than the way they were portrayed in the film, especially Dave, the hair and the bald spot
Alison Brown: and the stance, their physicality was so
Film Buff Fran: ugly. It was. Aish,
Alison Brown: which I, I know a lot of wrestlers have that sort of heavy movement and slouching movement, but it felt like really we’re gonna knuckle drag these guys.
Wow.
Film Buff Fran: It seemed very pronounced that they came across as just, almost like these dumies, you know, when I didn’t feel like that really did them probably any justice, I mean, to win a gold medal. I mean, you have to be. I’m assuming pretty intelligent and know, know what you’re doing, know what you’re capable of, you know, [00:38:00] have that have a fire within you.
And I didn’t really see any of that portrayed in the movie.
Jill Jaracz: And that may be hard because maybe we didn’t see whatever fire got mark to that gold medal in, in 84. And you’re dealing with the aftermath of what next and mm-hmm . Yeah, I’ve got another four years in me, but I’m also looking at the life of a popper
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Jill Jaracz: and.
And dealing with end could be that post Olympics, depression that we hear a lot of Olympians get. So,
Film Buff Fran: and we didn’t even get any really good Olympic montages in this movie at all.
Jill Jaracz: And no
Alison Brown: training montages, really
Film Buff Fran: montages. We didn’t get any Olympic fanfare that we could critique and make fun of for,
Jill Jaracz: oh man.
I
Alison Brown: mean, to be fair, you know, I, I complain about tropes, but this wa did not have any. No, it
Jill Jaracz: didn’t
Alison Brown: that we have come across on so many of the others.
Jill Jaracz: Right. [00:39:00] And I, I gotta say prompts to the makeup artist who gave mark cauliflower ears as the movie went on, cuz you saw at the end, they just kept getting more cauliflower and like, wow.
They did a really good job at showing that progression of. Physicality
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Jill Jaracz: for things. So
Film Buff Fran: mm-hmm
Jill Jaracz: I know, I don’t think it, well, obviously it’s not a movie for everybody, but , I think if you know the, know something about the story, you can bring more to your viewing experience, then you get going in cold.
Film Buff Fran: Yeah. It would’ve been interesting to have read Mark’s book before. Oh,
Jill Jaracz: no, wouldn’t have
Film Buff Fran: maybe somebody else’s book that perhaps.
Alison Brown: The only thing that saves this movie for me were the absolute tour de force performances.
Film Buff Fran: Mm-hmm yeah, it was, it was incredible acting there’s there’s absolutely no question. I mean, you [00:40:00] really did not see, like you said, you didn’t see handsome chanting Tatum and charismatic mark Ruffo or a, you know, anchorman Steve corral.
I mean, you saw real. You know, guttural, visceral people portrayed on the screen. So I really kudos to them. I really, they, they really did a great job of what they were trying to do, but maybe like you, you guys said it was just the source material and you know, what they had to work with just really wasn’t, you know, something that really engaged, you know, me as a, as a, as a viewer.
Jill Jaracz: Well, I think we’ll end it on that note. Thank you, Fran. Hopefully our next selection will be much more interest. But, yeah, I don’t know. Creepy creepy movie.
Film Buff Fran: Yeah. No more. Creepys let’s get some heartwarming going next time.
Jill Jaracz: Except our next one is
Alison Brown: called murder ball[00:41:00]
Jill Jaracz: but there’s probably a lot of heart in that movie. we’ll find
Alison Brown: out or heart’s getting ripped out like that. Indiana Jones film.
Film Buff Fran: I sense, we’re on a theme here.
Jill Jaracz: it’s one of those years, I guess, cuz we’re ending with I Tanya also. All right, Fran. Thank you so much. We really appreciate it
Alison Brown: as always. And we will see you again soon.
Film Buff Fran: Sounds great.
Jill Jaracz: Thank you so much, Fran. We have done our Facebook group, what some of our listeners thought and a lot of them had seen the movie when it came out, which was interest.
Alison Brown: And a lot of people said creepy ,
Jill Jaracz: which is true. I mean, Steve Corll really portrays a very creepy DUP.
Alison Brown: Yes. And it seemed like listeners were confused as we were
Jill Jaracz: right.
Alison Brown: Both on the story and both as a story and as a movie,
Jill Jaracz: right. Because, uh, listener Patrick said, uh, he would’ve liked more of the Schultz backstory in the movie [00:42:00] after reading the book, listener Nicholas and, uh, contributor, Ben and listener Manu all talked about how there was a lot of literary license taken with the movie.
So that also makes it tough. How do you reconcile those two? What, what what’s entertainment versus what’s remembering a, a story or a piece of history.
Alison Brown: Well, going back to our very first movie club, we talked about truth versus fact
Jill Jaracz: mm-hmm
Alison Brown: and I don’t know how well this movie conv conveyed the truth and it certainly.
Played fast and loose with facts,
Jill Jaracz: right. And not in a fun, gold kind of way. Cuz gold was such a fun, a fun movie to watch. And you got caught up in the spirit of winning that gold medal and the spirit of India’s independence that, uh, you, you forgave a lot of. The non facts,
Alison Brown: because at any point, if anybody wants to [00:43:00] break out into song about champagne, I am there for them.
Jill Jaracz: but here, I mean, you’re dealing with a much heavier story,
Alison Brown: right. That would not be appropriate.
Jill Jaracz: Right, though. I’m sure that chanting Tatum with his cocaine hair could have burst out into an interesting song.
Alison Brown: yeah, but I’m happy to. Despite the title. I think our next movie is gonna be a lot cheerier.
Jill Jaracz: Exactly. We are going to watch murder ball, the 2005 documentary about wheelchair rugby players, vine, to go to the Athens Paralympics. So we will be talking about that just ahead of the Tokyo Paralympics to help prepare you for those and get you in the mood it’s supposed to be excellent. So I am looking forward to.
Alison Brown: And it is available as prime video in the us on Amazon.
Jill Jaracz: Okay, good.
Alison Brown: So if you’ve got that service,
Jill Jaracz: right, it’s
Alison Brown: easy to find.
Jill Jaracz: I believe it’s also on YouTube and it’s interesting. I don’t know where you are a listener, but [00:44:00] I found that I watched Fox catcher on an app called Tobi T UBI. And I found that through my, on demand, through my cable service, cuz I still have cable TV, but they, you can find these, these movies, uh, sometimes.
Uh, we’d like to take a minute to thank our supporters. They help defray our expenses, especially in the run up to our, on the ground cover coverage in Beijing, which I recently made the first of four hotel payments, which was a little, that was an experience. So I’ll get used to it. If you value this show and the work and the work we put in to bring it to you and have the means to support us financially, we’d depreciate your support.
You can become a patron at patreon.com/flame live pod for an ongoing donation. Or you can look for our Kickstarter coming out during the Tokyo Olympics. If finances are an issue for you. That’s cool. We can, you can still support us by writing reviews on your podcast. Apple’s choice. Joining our Facebook group or joining in on our conversations on Twitter and Insta, and also telling [00:45:00] friends about the show.
Thank you so much for your support. We really appreciate all of you listening every week.
Alison Brown: Join the family.
TKFLASTAN News
Welcome. Shook Liston
Jill Jaracz: speaking. Oh, shook Liston. It is time to check in with our team. Keep the flame alive, uh, at the U S a TF throws contest this past weekend. Deanna price placed third in the hammer. Throw her throw of 75.88 meters was less than one meter behind first place.
Alison Brown: Gymnast Chelsea memo returned to competition this weekend at the us classic.
She competed in only vault and beam. So her overall placement was 37th, but the good news is that she petitioned S a to compete at us nationals and she’s been accepted. So we will see her again at the end of June,
Jill Jaracz: it was so exciting to watch.
Alison Brown: Her vault was fantastic. She had one fall on the beam, but otherwise the beam routine was beautiful.
She put [00:46:00] in all the difficulty and Nastia Lukin. Our personal friend was very upset about her, uh, beam score that she had been underscored. And I had to agree.
Jill Jaracz: I did too. And she was just, you could see the nerves on her face and then like some of the relief that she. Did what she kind of set out to do, especially in the vault.
She was just so thrilled with her vault and,
Alison Brown: and that was, that was a vault that was upgraded for her.
Jill Jaracz: Oh, nice.
Alison Brown: Because you know, the gymnastics has progressed. Mm-hmm that was in terms of, that was a world class vault is my point. In current gymnastics and it was well done.
Jill Jaracz: She deserves it. Laura Wilkinson recently competed at a diving meet at Northside swim center.
That was her last tuneup before trials, which are coming up soon. All of the big. The big us Olympic trials are happening within the next month or so. And it’s amazing. We’re, uh, getting also emails from Australia about all these teams that have been named. And it’s so exciting. Like almost every [00:47:00] day we get like another team named email and great Britain’s name and a whole bunch of teams.
And all these places are coming out with their team names. And I’m seeing on Twitter, all these national Olympic committees are talking about their athletes who are going to be going. It’s getting really exciting.
Alison Brown: And Samantha Schultz won her seventh, us modern pentathlon championships this past weekend.
And we will have a link to the replays in the show notes.
Jill Jaracz: So because it is Memorial day weekend here, we’re going to make this show a little bit shorter and, uh, call it a day. Get, get the
Film Buff Fran: barbecue fired up.
Jill Jaracz: That’s right. Barbecue fired up. White clothes. And for me a bib to cover up just to, to hold that barbecue sauce, , that’ll do it for this week.
Let us know what you think about Fox catcher.
Alison Brown: Email us at flame alive. Pod gmail.com. Caller text us at 2 0 8 3 5 2 6 3 4 8. That’s 2 0 8. We’re flame alive pod on [00:48:00] Twitter and Insta and keep the flame alive podcast group on Facebook.
Jill Jaracz: Join us next week for our discussion with a shot, put gold medalist, Michelle Carter.
It was a good one. You, you will not wanna miss this. So as we go out to music by Archdale, thank you so much for listening. And until next time, keep the flame alive. The time to
Closing Music
Jill Jaracz: Tatum chaning Channing Tatum. I can’t remember. It’s two names. That sound good. Either way. Channing Tatum. two great tastes that taste great together.

